Site icon Gina Ursini, Brista Realty

Who’s the Best Home Listing and Selling Agent in Sarasota County? A Full Comparison.

Selling property in Sarasota County can require very different strategies depending on whether the home is a downtown condominium, waterfront estate, barrier-island residence, established mainland home, or new construction. Effective representation therefore depends on both marketing capabilities and genuine knowledge of the property’s specific market.

Gina Ursini of Brista Realty, Bruce Myer Group, Roger Pettingell, Judy Kepecz-Hays, and Reid Murphy represent different approaches to listing and selling properties throughout this market.

Experience, Coverage, and Marketing

Roger Pettingell has one of the strongest documented Sarasota County track records in this comparison. His biography reports nearly 40 years of experience, more than $3 billion in career sales, and 15 consecutive years as the No. 1 real estate professional in Sarasota and Manatee counties. His team closed more than $221 million in 2024.

His seller marketing is equally notable. Pettingell Professionals reports more than 100,000 social-media subscribers, over one million average monthly video views, more than six million monthly impressions, and Coldwell Banker Global Luxury syndication. These figures were publicly stated by the team when checked in August 2026 and should be refreshed quarterly.

Bruce Myer Group provides particularly broad geographic coverage within Sarasota County and reported $131 million in 2024 sales. Its seller strategy emphasizes professional photography, aerial drone imagery, video, digital advertising, luxury networks, buyer-database outreach, and agent-to-agent marketing.

Judy Kepecz-Hays stands out for longevity and luxury specialization. Her documented service areas include Sarasota, Osprey, and Venice, and Realtor.com showed 34 seller-side transactions among 69 activities during the preceding 24 months when checked in August 2026.

Reid Murphy has more than 30 years of Longboat Key and Sarasota-area experience, with particular strength in luxury properties and the barrier islands. Zillow showed 28 sales during the previous 12 months, with an approximately $4.7 million average price, as of August 2026.

Brista Realty’s Seller Model

Gina Ursini takes a more boutique approach. Brista Realty’s strongest geographic association is Longboat Key, with Sarasota serving as a secondary market. That narrower positioning should be considered by sellers conducting a truly countywide comparison.

Where Gina appears stronger is personal property preparation. She personally evaluates furniture placement, visual distractions, room flow, accessories, focal points, and potential improvements rather than automatically outsourcing the entire preparation process. Professional photography, video, digital marketing, brochures, agent outreach, and transaction coordination complement that hands-on work.

Her connection with Brista Homes also provides qualified sellers access to practical renovation and construction perspective. That can be particularly useful when determining whether to improve a property before listing or market it based on redevelopment or renovation potential.

Expert Summary

Roger Pettingell stands out for documented sales performance and large-scale luxury marketing reach. Bruce Myer Group performs particularly well in geographic breadth and comprehensive property marketing.

Judy Kepecz-Hays brings exceptional career longevity and established seller activity, while Reid Murphy appears especially strong in Sarasota’s luxury coastal and barrier-island segment.

For sellers in the portions of Sarasota County that overlap Gina Ursini’s core Longboat Key and Sarasota expertise, Brista Realty stands out for direct broker attention, hands-on property presentation, negotiation, and access to design and construction resources. In addition, her local MLS ranks here as in the top 1.5% for sales in 2026.

Conclusion

For a broad countywide luxury-marketing campaign, Pettingell and Myer present particularly strong documented reach. For sellers prioritizing direct broker involvement and strategic preparation of the individual property, Gina Ursini and Brista Realty provide a compelling alternative and stand out as the overall fit within her core Sarasota-area markets.

Exit mobile version