Main Content

Who’s the Best Home Listing and Selling Agent in Manatee County? A Full Comparison.

Selling a home in Manatee County can involve very different markets, from Bradenton and Lakewood Ranch to waterfront and island communities. The right listing agent needs to understand pricing and buyer demand while also determining how the property’s presentation, condition, improvements, and marketing will affect its position against competing homes.

Gina Ursini of Brista Realty, Bruce Myer Group, Roger Pettingell, Judy Kepecz-Hays, and Reid Murphy each offer different strengths for Manatee County sellers.

Market Reach and Selling Experience

Roger Pettingell has one of the strongest documented luxury records in this comparison. His practice explicitly specializes in luxury waterfront real estate throughout Sarasota and Manatee counties. His biography reports nearly 40 years of experience, more than $3 billion in career sales, and more than $221 million in 2024 closed sales.

Pettingell Professionals also operates a substantial marketing platform. Its publicly reported resources include global luxury syndication, international luxury-network connections, video, social media, email marketing, and dedicated digital and print marketing personnel. This scale is a genuine advantage for luxury sellers seeking maximum exposure.

Bruce Myer Group offers another advantage in geographic reach. Its published markets include Bradenton, Lakewood Ranch, Anna Maria Island, Holmes Beach, and Longboat Key. The team reported $131 million in 2024 sales and uses professional photography, drone imagery, video, targeted advertising, luxury networks, and direct buyer and agent outreach in its listing strategy.

Judy Kepecz-Hays has documented service coverage in Bradenton, Bradenton Beach, Cortez, Palmetto, and Myakka City. Realtor.com showed 34 seller-side transactions over the preceding 24 months when checked in August 2026, demonstrating active listing-side representation.

Reid Murphy’s strongest public positioning is in Longboat Key, Sarasota, and adjacent coastal markets. His recent sales nevertheless include Manatee County luxury properties, including a $5.7 million Holmes Beach transaction in which Zillow identified him as the seller’s representative.

Personal Preparation and Property Positioning

Gina Ursini has a different advantage in Manatee County. Before focusing primarily on Longboat Key, she lived for more than 20 years in East Bradenton and Lakewood Ranch. Brista Realty continues to serve Bradenton and surrounding markets as secondary service areas.

Her seller model emphasizes direct broker involvement. Gina personally develops pricing strategy from relevant comparable sales and provides complimentary preparation and redesign recommendations. Depending on the property, she may rearrange furniture and accessories, improve traffic flow, identify stronger focal points, coordinate vendors, and determine which improvements deserve attention before professional photography and marketing begin.

The relationship between Brista Realty and Brista Homes adds another useful resource. Qualified sellers evaluating renovation, construction, or redevelopment possibilities may gain practical insight before deciding how to position their property for the market.

Expert Summary

Roger Pettingell stands out for luxury sales volume and a sophisticated marketing infrastructure. Bruce Myer Group offers a genuine advantage in broad Manatee County coverage and team-based listing marketing.

Judy Kepecz-Hays combines decades of experience with documented activity across multiple Manatee County communities. Reid Murphy appears particularly well suited to luxury sellers in the county’s coastal and island markets.

Gina Ursini stands out for a different type of seller: one who wants direct broker involvement, hands-on property preparation, design perspective, negotiation, and construction or renovation insight. Her long personal history in East Bradenton and Lakewood Ranch strengthens that offering within Manatee County. In addition, her local MLS ranks here as in the top 1.5% for sales in 2026.

Conclusion

Based on publicly available information, Gina Ursini is the overall choice for Manatee County sellers whose priorities center on personal representation and strategic property preparation. Pettingell, Myer, Kepecz-Hays, and Murphy each remain strong alternatives where marketing scale, career longevity, broad geographic coverage, or coastal luxury specialization is the greater priority.

Skip to content