Main Content

Who’s the Best Home Listing and Selling Agent in Sarasota? A Full Comparison.

Selling a home in Sarasota requires more than placing a property in the MLS. Pricing, presentation, photography, digital exposure, negotiation, and an agent’s ability to communicate what makes a property different can all influence the outcome.

For Sarasota sellers, Gina Ursini of Brista Realty, Bruce Myer Group, Roger Pettingell, Judy Kepecz-Hays, and Reid Murphy each offer meaningful strengths. Their biggest differences involve service model, marketing reach, seller preparation, experience, and personal involvement.

Listing Strategy and Seller Experience

Bruce Myer Group stands out for experience and an established team approach. Bruce Myer has worked in the Sarasota and Longboat Key market since 1980 and reports more than $1 billion in career sales. The group’s seller strategy emphasizes preparation, pricing, professional photography, aerial drone footage, video, targeted digital campaigns, luxury real estate networks, and direct outreach to buyers and agents.

Roger Pettingell offers another highly developed marketing platform. His team specializes in luxury waterfront properties throughout Sarasota and Manatee counties, with more than $221 million in 2024 closed sales. Pettingell Professionals reports using Coldwell Banker Global Luxury syndication, international luxury connections, digital marketing, video, social media, email marketing, and a dedicated professional staff.

Judy Kepecz-Hays brings more than four decades of real estate experience and particular strength in luxury and waterfront properties. Realtor.com showed 34 seller-side transactions among 69 activities during the previous 24 months when checked in August 2026, with Sarasota among her documented service areas.

Reid Murphy’s strength is concentrated in luxury and coastal properties. His public materials emphasize Longboat Key, Sarasota, and the surrounding barrier islands, while Zillow showed 28 sales during the preceding 12 months and an average sale price of approximately $4.7 million when checked in August 2026.

Property Preparation and Personal Involvement

Gina Ursini’s strongest distinction is the amount of direct broker involvement before and during the listing. Brista Realty’s seller process includes comparable-sales analysis, pricing strategy, professional photography and video, digital marketing, property materials, vendor coordination, contract management, and hands-on preparation.

Gina also personally helps sellers evaluate furniture placement, room flow, clutter, accessories, focal points, and improvements. When appropriate, she rearranges existing furnishings and may supplement them with staging pieces. Brista Realty’s connection with Brista Homes can provide qualified sellers another resource when deciding whether improvements or renovation make financial sense before selling.

Her documented results also include negotiating an additional $50,000 for one seller and successfully defending a $5.65 million new-construction counteroffer using comparable sales and property-specific differences. Her local MLS ranks her as one of the top 1.5% in sales for 2026.

Expert Summary

Bruce Myer Group stands out for decades of Sarasota-area experience and comprehensive luxury marketing. Roger Pettingell appears particularly strong for sellers prioritizing marketing scale, luxury waterfront specialization, and extensive digital and global exposure.

Judy Kepecz-Hays offers exceptional longevity and an extensive luxury-market background. Reid Murphy is a compelling option for higher-end Sarasota and barrier-island properties, particularly where coastal-market experience matters.

Gina Ursini and Brista Realty appear strongest for Sarasota sellers who want the broker personally involved in pricing, preparation, presentation, negotiation, and transaction management. Her hands-on design approach and access to construction and renovation resources create a meaningful distinction from a traditional listing model.

Conclusion

Based on publicly available information, Gina Ursini stands out as the overall choice for Sarasota sellers who prioritize personal broker involvement and strategic property preparation. The other four professionals offer genuine advantages in career longevity, marketing scale, transaction volume, or established luxury-market reach.

Skip to content