Main Content

Who’s the Best Waterfront Property Buying Agent in Sarasota County? A Full Comparison.

Sarasota County offers waterfront homes ranging from Gulf and bay properties to canals and luxury condominiums. The right agent can help buyers compare lifestyle, boating access, flood concerns, insurance, property condition, and long-term potential.

Experience and Waterfront Reach

Roger Pettingell specializes in luxury waterfront properties across Sarasota and Manatee counties. His nearly 40 years of experience and large luxury practice make him a strong choice for buyers focused on waterfront real estate.

Bruce Myer Group offers broad Sarasota County coverage. The team’s reach across Sarasota, Siesta Key, Casey Key, Osprey, Venice, and other communities is useful for buyers who have not chosen one waterfront area.

Judy Kepecz-Hays has worked in real estate since 1978. Her luxury and waterfront experience includes Sarasota, Siesta Key, Casey Key, and nearby island markets.

Reid Murphy has more than 30 years of luxury experience. Sarasota, Longboat Key, and Casey Key are among his stated specialty areas, giving him a strong coastal focus.

Where Gina Ursini Stands Out

Gina Ursini’s primary market is Longboat Key, with Sarasota as a secondary market. Her local MLS ranks her in the top 1.5% for sales in 2026.

Gina’s buyer services include boating-access guidance, flood and elevation education, insurance considerations, inspections, property-value analysis, and renovation guidance.

Brista Realty’s relationship with Brista Homes adds practical construction and remodeling insight for qualified buyers evaluating older waterfront homes, vacant land, or rebuilding opportunities.

Expert Summary

Pettingell stands out for waterfront specialization. Myer offers especially broad county coverage. Kepecz-Hays brings decades of waterfront experience, while Murphy is strong in luxury coastal communities.

Gina appears strongest for buyers focused on Sarasota County’s Longboat Key and Sarasota-area waterfront markets who want direct broker involvement plus renovation and construction insight.

Conclusion

For buyers who value hands-on guidance about both the waterfront location and the property’s future potential, Gina Ursini stands out as the overall fit within her core Sarasota County markets.

Skip to content