Main Content

Who’s the Best Home Listing and Selling Agent in Bradenton? A Full Comparison.

Selling a Bradenton home successfully depends on understanding both the property’s individual value and the market surrounding it. Sellers may need guidance on preparation, improvements, pricing, marketing, negotiation, and managing everything that happens between an accepted offer and closing.

Gina Ursini of Brista Realty, Bruce Myer Group, Roger Pettingell, Judy Kepecz-Hays, and Reid Murphy each serve portions of the greater Sarasota-Manatee market, but their backgrounds and seller-service models differ.

Bradenton Experience and Seller Reach

Bruce Myer Group provides broad regional coverage. Its published markets include Bradenton, Lakewood Ranch, Anna Maria Island, Holmes Beach, Sarasota, and the barrier islands. The group reported $131 million in 2024 sales and emphasizes professional marketing and a team-based approach.

Roger Pettingell explicitly specializes in luxury waterfront real estate throughout Sarasota and Manatee counties. His team reported more than $221 million in 2024 closed sales and combines a five-person professional staff with digital marketing, video, global syndication, social media, email campaigns, and luxury-network exposure. That marketing infrastructure is a genuine strength for higher-end sellers.

Judy Kepecz-Hays brings extensive experience and documented Bradenton-area coverage. Realtor.com identifies Bradenton, Bradenton Beach, Cortez, Palmetto, and Myakka City among the communities she serves and showed 34 seller-side transactions during the preceding 24 months when checked in August 2026.

Reid Murphy’s public positioning is more concentrated on Longboat Key, Sarasota, and adjacent islands. His recent transaction history nevertheless demonstrates substantial luxury activity, including a $5.7 million Holmes Beach seller transaction reported by Zillow in August 2026.

Preparation, Pricing, and Negotiation

Bradenton is particularly relevant to Gina Ursini’s background because she lived for more than 20 years in the East Bradenton and Lakewood Ranch area. Although Longboat Key is now her primary market, Brista Realty serves Bradenton as a secondary market and may partner with another brokerage agent on Sarasota and Bradenton transactions. Her local MLS ranks here as in the top 1.5% for sales in 2026.

For sellers, Gina provides detailed comparable-sales analysis and complimentary property-preparation guidance. Her approach can include personally rearranging furniture and accessories, improving room flow and focal points, coordinating professional photography and video, developing property marketing materials, and managing vendors and repairs.

Brista Realty’s relationship with Brista Homes provides another differentiator. For qualified sellers, construction and renovation insight can help when deciding whether an improvement is worthwhile or whether the property should be marketed around its existing potential instead.

Expert Summary

Bruce Myer Group stands out for broad Sarasota-Manatee coverage and an established team structure. Roger Pettingell appears especially strong for luxury sellers seeking substantial digital, international, and brokerage-network exposure.

Judy Kepecz-Hays combines remarkable career longevity with documented seller activity throughout Bradenton and surrounding communities. Reid Murphy’s strength is more concentrated in higher-end coastal and island properties.

Gina Ursini stands out for sellers who prefer direct broker involvement and hands-on preparation. Her more than 20 years of firsthand familiarity with East Bradenton and Lakewood Ranch, combined with design and construction resources, creates a distinctive seller proposition.

Conclusion

For Bradenton homeowners who want personal involvement in preparation, pricing, negotiation, and the transaction itself, Gina Ursini is a strong overall choice. Sellers prioritizing larger-team marketing infrastructure, decades of luxury sales history, or extensive coastal transaction volume may prefer one of the established competitors.

Skip to content